To God, About God, Before One Another

Vertical Praise, Horizontal Witness, and the Recovery
of a Biblical Philosophy of Christian Song

❧ ✦ ❧

Introduction: When the Band Steps Down

On any given Sunday, somewhere in America, a congregation stands in a darkened room while a band on a brightly lit platform plays the opening bars of the morning’s “worship.” Haze drifts across the stage. A vocalist closes her eyes. The lyrics on the screen speak of feelings, of breakthrough, of a presence that seems to arrive on cue with the bridge. Forty minutes later the band steps down, the house lights come up, and the pastor walks to the pulpit, where, by common assumption, worship has just ended, and something else is about to begin.

That assumption deserves scrutiny. It treats music as the sum of worship, the musician as its mediator, and the congregation’s feelings as evidence that God has drawn near. Every one of those premises is contestable from Scripture. Yet the opposite error is equally real: churches that sing doctrinally correct songs with cold indifference, or that suspect any song not addressed directly to God of being somehow less than sacred.

The modern Christian songwriter stands between these errors, and the question before him is not merely stylistic. It is theological. To whom is this song addressed? What does it teach? What will it form in the people who sing it? Does it belong in the gathered church, or does it serve a different, though still legitimate, purpose? This essay argues that God-honoring Christian song must hold a deliberate balance: priority given to direct, vertical address to God, alongside a biblically warranted horizontal ministry of testimony, doctrine, and mutual admonition. It further argues that songwriters who intend to keep that balance should commit their convictions to writing.

The Vertical Priority: Singing to God

The Psalter, the inspired hymnal of Israel and the church, overwhelmingly directs its voice toward God: “O sing unto the LORD a new song: sing unto the LORD, all the earth” (Ps. 96:1). The worship of heaven in Revelation 4–5 is unmistakably vertical. The elders and living creatures do not sing about the Lamb to one another; they sing to Him: “Thou art worthy” (Rev. 5:9). Paul’s instruction in Ephesians 5:19 ends with the same orientation: “singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord.”

This is why corporate praise loses something essential when it only talks about God and never to Him. Songs of adoration, confession, and petition place the congregation in the posture of the redeemed before the throne. The RCA Commission on Worship states the principle with admirable economy:

“Music is made first of all to the Lord and only secondarily to each other.”

— RCA Commission on Worship, “The Theology and Place of Music in Worship,” Faithward.org

Pastor Paul Chappell reaches the same conclusion from Colossians 3:16, observing that the verse which tells believers what to sing also tells them how and to whom they sing: “with grace in your hearts to the Lord.” Spirit-generated, Bible-centered singing, he argues, will always be directed toward the Lord as its audience.

“Our emphasis in it should be where God’s emphasis is—on Him!”

— Dr. Paul Chappell, “Two Essential Elements of God-Honoring Music”

The vertical priority is not a matter of taste. It flows from the first commandment’s claim that God alone is the proper object of worship, and it guards the gathered church against the subtle drift in which singing becomes self-expression dressed in sanctified vocabulary.

The Horizontal Dimension: Testimony, Doctrine, and Admonition

Yet Scripture refuses to make direct address the only legitimate form of sacred song. The same verse that directs song “to the Lord” begins, “Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs” (Eph. 5:19). Colossians 3:16 is even more explicit: the word of Christ dwells richly as believers are “teaching and admonishing one another.” Daniel Webster of the Free Will Baptist Music Commission calls this verse perhaps the most concise philosophy of church music in Scripture and identifies its twofold purpose: praise rendered to God, and the teaching and admonishing of the singer through the Word. He frames both under one governing aim:

“The primary purpose of church music is to worship and praise the Lord.”

— Daniel Webster, “The Purpose for Music in the Church,” fwbworship.com

Webster’s point is that the second purpose does not compete with the first; faithful teaching in song serves God’s praise. Many psalms are themselves horizontal. Psalm 1 addresses the reader, not God. Psalm 42 is addressed to the psalmist’s own soul: “Why art thou cast down, O my soul?” Psalm 133 celebrates the unity of brethren. The canon also includes Esther, which never names God, and wisdom literature such as Ecclesiastes, which works through human experience by reflection rather than prayer. If inspired Scripture can teach, lament, and exhort without direct address, so can a faithful song.

John MacArthur’s exposition of Ephesians 5:19 offers a useful taxonomy: psalms that exalt God’s person and work, hymns that celebrate salvation, and spiritual songs that testify to the Lord’s work in the believer’s heart. Gospel songs of testimony, such as “Blessed Assurance” and “It Is Well with My Soul,” belong squarely in that third category.

Worship Music and Christian Music

It is therefore helpful to distinguish worship music in the strict sense (vertical praise and prayer offered to God in the gathered assembly) from Christian music in the broader sense (songs of life, hope, struggle, and gospel invitation meant to encourage believers or reach the unconverted). Both can be spiritually valid. The error lies in confusing them: treating a performance ballad as congregational praise, or dismissing a sound testimony song because it does not open with “Lord, You are.” W. Robert Godfrey observes that the Psalms model the needed balance, holding the declaration of God’s truth together with the worshiper’s emotional response, and he warns that our songs easily become either too informational or too subjective and man-centered. The Psalter also supplies the full emotional range, including the laments that Adriel Sanchez notes are underrepresented in many contemporary song sets.

Music Unfit for the Sanctuary

Not every song that bears a Christian label belongs in the house of God. Scripture records music placed in the service of idolatry: the revelry before the golden calf (Exod. 32:17–19), and the orchestra of Nebuchadnezzar that signaled the moment to bow before the image (Dan. 3:5). Through Amos, God told a religiously busy but disobedient people, “Take thou away from me the noise of thy songs” (Amos 5:23). Music offered from unrepentant hearts is merely noise to heaven.

Contemporary forms of unfit music fall into several recognizable patterns. The first is doctrinal error set to melody: prosperity themes, a Holy Spirit who must be summoned or “invited” into a room (though He already indwells every believer), or a God portrayed as merely reacting to circumstances. The second is man-centered sentimentality, in which “I” and “me” crowd out the attributes and acts of God. The third is atmospheric manipulation. MacArthur describes services in darkened rooms with sensual music and flashing lights, which he argues produce a passing feeling rather than true worship. Dave Jenkins of Servants of Grace adds a fourth: songs that treat Jesus as little more than a boyfriend or reduce the Trinity to a vague “presence.”

Ben Ditzel’s Worship through Song Project issues a sober warning that applies far beyond any single artist:

“Not all music marketed under the Christian label is … worthy of being sung.”

— Ben Ditzel, “Discernment,” The Worship through Song Project

Both Ditzel and Jenkins raise particular concerns about music from movements such as Bethel, Hillsong, and Elevation, pointing not only to individual lyrics but to the broader teaching of the ministries that produce them.

The Gray Areas of Song Selection

Honesty requires admitting that many questions in worship music are genuinely difficult. GotQuestions.org identifies several: hymn writers whose personal theology was flawed (Horatio Spafford did not believe in eternal hell; Francis of Assisi was Roman Catholic); songwriters who later fall into public sin; lyrics whose author meant something different from what the singers mean; and licensing royalties that route money back to the producing ministry. To these one could add instrumentation and rhythm, volume, repetition, the long-running debate over exclusive psalmody, and the cultural setting of each congregation.

On such questions believers of good conscience disagree, and Romans 14 cautions against despising a brother over disputable matters. Yet gray areas are no excuse for indifference. GotQuestions supplies a simple test for any lyric:

“If we wouldn’t … say it, we shouldn’t sing it.”

— GotQuestions.org, “Can a Christian worship God using music from a church with unbiblical teachings?”

The same article counsels wisdom to choose the best songs for a particular congregation, grace to distinguish personal preference from vital doctrine, and humility to hold convictions while living at peace with fellow believers. Jenkins likewise concedes that evaluating a song’s source requires nuance, even as he argues that platforming problematic ministries carries real pastoral risk.

Worship, Not Entertainment

Outside the church, music exists largely to please its audience. Inside the church, the audience is God. MacArthur insists that the redeemed do not gather to entertain one another or unbelievers; the controlling question for all church music is whether it glorifies God, not whether it entertains. Webster likewise argues that drawing sinners and “preparing the heart for preaching” are healthy by-products of church music, not its primary purpose.

Godfrey sounds a sobering historical note. Music occupies a modest place in the New Testament record, yet in many modern churches it has become central, with prayer, Scripture reading, and preaching reduced to make room for it.

“For many churchgoers, it would appear that music has become a new sacrament.”

— W. Robert Godfrey, “Music Acceptable to God,” Modern Reformation

John Calvin anticipated the danger nearly five centuries ago:

“Such songs as have been composed only for the sweetness and delight of the ear are unbecoming to the majesty of the church.”

— John Calvin, as cited by the RCA Commission on Worship, Faithward.org

Worship Is More Than Music: Rethinking the “Worship Leader”

Perhaps no modern habit of speech reveals the confusion more clearly than the phrase “now let’s enter into worship,” spoken just as the band begins. MacArthur is direct:

“Music is a means to express worship, but it is not worship.”

— John MacArthur, “Is Music Worship?” Grace to You

Worship in Scripture is the whole-life response of the redeemed: “present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service” (Rom. 12:1). It includes prayer, the reading and preaching of the Word, giving, the Lord’s Table, obedience, and service to the needy. Jon Davis, surveying the 254 occurrences of “worship” in the NIV, counted only three in a musical context. One of them is telling: “all the congregation worshipped, and the singers sang, and the trumpeters sounded” (2 Chron. 29:28). The musicians made music while the assembly worshipped.

Hence the difficulty with the modern title “Worship Leader” when it designates a person whose only responsibility is the musical set. If worship encompasses the whole service and the whole life, the title either claims too much for the musician or implies too little about everything else. Biblically, oversight of the church’s worship belongs to its shepherds, who are charged to feed the flock and guard it from error (Acts 20:28). A musician may serve faithfully as a song leader or minister of music, but calling him the worship leader quietly redefines worship as music and the preaching of the Word as something other than worship. Davis puts it memorably:

“A real worship leader drops the mic.”

— Jon Davis, “Worship does not mean singing and music,” Medium

The caution is not against skilled musicians, who serve the church as the Levitical singers served the temple. It is against a title and job description that make the platform the place where worship happens and the musician the one who makes it happen.

The Case for a Written Philosophy of Music

Given the stakes, Christian songwriters and the churches that select their songs should not leave their convictions unspoken. A written philosophy of music grounded in Scripture functions much as a doctrinal statement does: it settles questions in advance, resists the pull of trends, and provides accountability. Chris Anderson, writing at SharperIron, laments the casualties of the worship wars:

“We have focused more on style than on substance.”

— Chris Anderson, “A Philosophy of Worship Music,” SharperIron

Anderson proposes that worship music be intentionally Scriptural, God-glorifying, Christ-centered, congregational, fervent, and distinct. Building on that framework, a songwriter’s written philosophy should address at least the following:

  • Theological foundation: a confession of faith and a commitment to Scripture as the final authority over every lyric.
  • Audience and address: when a song is written to God, about God, or to fellow believers, and how each serves the gathered church.
  • Textual standards: doctrinal clarity, Christ-centeredness, biblical vocabulary, and avoidance of vague or man-centered language.
  • Musical standards: tunes that serve the text, suit congregational voices, and fit the weight of the words.
  • Emotional integrity: music that evokes rather than manipulates, and that makes room for lament as well as joy.
  • Accountability: submission of texts to pastoral or theological review before public use.

Such discipline matters because songs form theology. Adriel Sanchez notes that in the early church, hymns supplied raw material for the creeds, and he warns that heterodox lyrics do lasting harm:

“Biblically sound song lyrics plant the truth of God’s Word deep in our hearts.”

— Adriel Sanchez, “What Is Worship Music For? 5 Reasons to Sing,” Logos

Jenkins states the pastoral application bluntly:

“Pastors, don’t hand over the theological direction of your church to a Spotify playlist.”

— Dave Jenkins, “How and Why Christians Can Exercise Discernment in the Songs They Sing,” Servants of Grace

Conclusion: Soli Deo Gloria

Modern songwriters need not choose between vertical adoration and horizontal witness. Scripture supplies both, in proportion. Songs that rise directly to the throne take priority, while songs of testimony, doctrine, and admonition serve the body as the word of Christ dwells richly. What the songwriter may not do is surrender either dimension to the market, the mood, or the platform. Music is a gift, but it is not a substitute for worship; the musician is a servant, not worship’s mediator. MacArthur reminds us that Johann Sebastian Bach inscribed soli Deo gloria, “glory to God alone,” on his compositions. That remains the right inscription for every song a Christian writes, and the right test for every song a church sings.

❧ ✦ ❧

Scripture quotations are from the King James Version.

Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *